In the first place debit cards are a bad idea. They don’t have the same protection as credit cards. Banks pushed them in the USA because of the huge fees they charged (hidden from users). Now those banks are not allowed to charge the hugely excessive fees (compared to any other country) they had been charging retailers. And the banks are now trying to push huge fees onto those using the cards. Just dump any debit card you have.
Secondly, you should have long ago severed any ties with the large banks (that not surprisingly are the ones announcing the huge fees, so far). They provide lousy service and extract exorbitant fees whenever they can sneak them by you. Choosing to do business with companies that you must remain hyper vigilante to abuse from is just not sensible. Small banks unfortunately get bought out by the large banks to prevent competition. So while using small banks is ok, you keep having to go to a new one as the large ones buy out your bank to prevent the competition.
So it is more sensible to just pick a credit union. Credit unions are decent overall. Some can still be bad choices but it is almost impossible to do worse than any of the large banks. If you use ATMs a good deal make sure you minimize ATM fees when selecting a credit union (their policies in that area – waived fees, network ATM access… are significantly different between your options).
The free checking we have grown accustom to may well be on the way out. That seems fine to me. Essentially the government’s subsidy to the large banks and financial institutions in repressing short term interest rates (at the expense of course of savers and retirees) has greatly reduced the value of checking and savings balances at banks. I am sure the large banks will be the most customer unfriendly as fees are added to accounts, based on their track record.
Obviously you should not carry credit card balances, with high interest rates.
There really is almost no excuse for dealing with the large banks (other than a mortgage that was sold to them without your permission where you have no option but to put up with their behavior as their customer). Many of the other extremely bad customer service industries (cable TV, internet access providers, airlines) have monopolistic powers than often make it extremely difficult to avoid dealing with them. Of course the large banks make huge anti-competitive moves that shouldn’t allowed in any capitalistic system. But then our system is more about what you can buy with your cash payments to congress than capitalism. And you can’t accept the proponents claims of capitalism as a reason to do what they ask; more often then not those playing the capitalism over government argument are asking for anti-capitalist measures (allowing anti-competitive practices etc.) in support of special interest at the expense of society (markets require regulation to have the benefits of competition provide a dividend to society).
Related: Credit Card Regulation Has Reduced Abuse By Banks – Credit Card Issuers Still Seeking to Take Your Money – More Outrageous Credit Card Fees
Comments
3 Comments so far
“In the first place debit cards are a bad idea. They don’t have the same protection as credit cards.”
You might want to qualify that. I’m pretty sure that all Visa and Mastercard debit cards have the exact same protection as a credit card.
I believe there is some truth to what you say: after many many complaints, they added some protections (as I remember it). However, I just checked the Visa site and I don’t see anything about replicating the right to dispute charges, for example.
Given finance companies history with trying to get away with every trick they can pull on their customers I would not assume you are protected unless they clearly and unambiguously say – there are no protections we provide for your credit card that are not provided for your debit card.
Others can chose to believe that the credit card companies are not trying to trick them in one way or the other. I wouldn’t take that path myself.
There are also legal differences, I believe. So even if Visa said we choose to treat the debit card exactly like a credit card in all ways – I don’t believe that impacts the law. And Visa can probably change their minds anytime they want (from the legal document I have seen the past they always say this).
Finance companies behavior over decades has led me to believe that trusting them to treat you fairly is unwise.
Hmm. Good point. I had always believed that Visa and MC cover debit same as credit. Looking at the site, Visa hedges its bet and does say you need to use the ‘credit’ option with its debit card to receive the protection. That is sketchy.