Provide easy, new access to credit facilitates sales. For that reason businesses want such easy access maintained. They don’t want people unable to buy just because they don’t have the money.
Financial institutions make a great deal of money providing easy access to credit. They don’t want to slow it down. While they do want to reduce fraud, they are perfectly happy to allow a fair amount of fraud while they can still make a lot of money.
What this means is the financial system has less incentive to eliminate identity theft than the people that have to clean up after it happens to them. There should be better ways to make identity theft much more difficult.
At a lessor level it should also be more difficult to steal one credit card (which also creates a big hassle for us, in trying to clean things up after fraud occurs). I suggested a way to make credit cards more secure and useful. When Apple Pay was announced I learned they are doing basically what I suggested.
Apple Pay doesn’t share information that can be used to steal your credit card. Apple Pay gives the retailer a 1 time use code for that purchase. It can’t be used, even if someone steals it to use your credit card for more purchases. I also believe Apple Pay doesn’t share other details with the retailer, though maybe I am wrong – I think it is just like you giving them cash (they don’t have your name, address, phone number, etc.).
Much of the information businesses share in the USA is considered private in Europe and companies are not allowed to share that personal information. This makes identity theft and invasions of your privacy more difficult. I wish the USA would move more in that direction.
If you have details stolen (a wallet…) you can put a note with credit agencies that results in them be less free to make it easy for financial institutions to give credit without sensible protections against misuse. But you can’t do this just as a matter of course. I believe we should have the ability to protect ourselves from the massive headache caused by businesses providing credit in our name. But we don’t have such protection now, because of the big money in keeping credit super easy (and thus fraud fairly easy).
Having to clean up after identity you may well have to hire someone to help clean up your credit report. To do so, look for credit repair companies with good reviews and a good reputation.
I would imagine choosing to put in extra protections against identity theft would mean we would have less easy access to credit. For example, I wish I could say you cannot provide a new credit under my name that isn’t using my address on file and without confirmation from my email. Also you are required to send an email, send a text message and send a postal letter, and update my credit agency file (in a way I can view) one week before credit is allowed.
There should also be options such as you must get a positive reply from me. A citizen choosing to have better protection against identity theft would give up immediate access to credit. But I would happily do so. I believe millions of others would too. And given how many people are victims every years, millions or hundreds of thousand a new customers for such a service would likely result.
Comments
6 Comments so far
John, you might be interested in some recent news about Apple Pay and security. I don’t recall which security blog that I follow mentioned this. Bottom line: banks are subverting the security of Apple Pay.
I had read about that, essentially banks were authorizing stolen credit cards for Apple Pay. Most banks have been taking new steps to improve the process to reduce this fraud.
Putting in security steps costs banks money to implement and puts in a burden that may reduce use – so banks often do less than you would hope they would to be careful (less than I imagine intelligent people would guess that they do).
The banks and credit card companies do spend huge amounts on anti-fraud measures. It is just they are still not doing nearly as well as they should, and some things are really lame (like the ancient card technology until very recently in the USA – we were far behind the rest of the world in card security measures). And reading about some of their actions on Apple Pay also show some amazing lapses in thinking of security.
John, another site, krebsonsecurity.com, just released a post about Apple Pay. Salient quote: “…the way Apple and the banks have implemented it actually makes card fraud cheaper and easier for fraudsters.”
I would also be in favor of giving up immediate access to my credit if I was assured more security. With the way that large companies have been hacked lately, it makes me nervous all around.
[…] Protecting Your Privacy and Security (2015) – Making Credit Cards More Secure and Useful (2014) – Governments Shouldn’t […]
[…] Protecting Your Privacy and Financial Security – Protect Yourself from Credit Card Fraud – Improvements to Credit Collection […]